
Many schools hold regular data meetings to review student performance, but these meetings often fail to lead to significant changes in instruction. A typical data meeting involves reviewing a spreadsheet with student scores, identifying areas where students are struggling, and discussing ways to reteach those concepts. However, this approach can be flawed because it focuses primarily on what teachers taught and how students scored, without examining what students actually understand.
A 7th grade math team, for example, might review a spreadsheet showing that many students are struggling with proportional relationships, and decide to reteach that concept. However, this decision is made without examining what those students actually understand, and may not address the underlying issues. Six weeks later, when the next benchmark assessment is administered, the team may find that student scores have barely improved.
This pattern is not unique to this team or school. Many data meetings follow a similar pattern, focusing on scores and reteaching concepts without examining the underlying student understanding. This approach can lead to a lack of progress in student learning, despite the time and effort invested in data meetings.
Understanding Student Thinking
To make better instructional decisions, educators need to understand what students are thinking and how they are reasoning. This requires examining evidence of student thinking, such as what students write, say, and do. However, this evidence is often not considered in data meetings, which can lead to a lack of understanding of what students truly know and need.
A writer who worked with their daughter on math problems found that her high scores on assessments did not necessarily mean she understood the underlying concepts. When she struggled with factoring polynomials, it became clear that she had been following procedures without understanding the ideas behind them.
Test scores can provide some information about what students have demonstrated on an assessment, but they do not reveal what students are thinking or how they are reasoning.
Leaving out evidence of student thinking can also have other costs. When data meetings focus primarily on scores, teachers may get the message that correct answers are the goal, rather than understanding and reasoning. This can lead to a focus on procedural practice, rather than deeper understanding and application of concepts.
This can involve reading student work, doing the math together, and examining student explanations and justifications.
Changing the Conversation
One way to change the conversation is to ask teachers to bring student work to the data meeting, along with what students said during the lesson. The team can then examine the work through the lens of mathematical practices, such as making sense of problems and persevering in solving them, or constructing viable arguments and critiquing the reasoning of others.
For example, a team might examine student work on a task involving proportional relationships, and look for evidence that students interpreted the problem, selected an approach, and revised their thinking. They might also look for evidence that students explained why their approaches made sense and responded to one another’s reasoning.
Before interpreting student work, the team can do the math together, solving the task themselves and comparing approaches. This can help them understand the mathematical ideas and identify potential misconceptions or areas of struggle.
This approach can also have equity implications, as it can help interrupt patterns of assumption and stereotype that may influence how teachers respond to student work.
A data meeting that focuses on examining evidence of student thinking can end with a decision that shows up in three places: the next lesson, the next walkthrough, and the next data meeting.
The principal can also play a key role in supporting this approach, by protecting time for the team to do the math together and examine student work, and by signaling that the purpose of the data meeting is to understand student thinking, not to evaluate teachers. By changing the conversation in data meetings, teams can focus on what really matters: understanding what students are thinking and how they are reasoning, and using that information to inform instructional decisions.
Dr. Pamela Seda, an educational consultant and author, notes that changing the conversation in data meetings requires a shift in focus from scores to student thinking. She suggests that teams can use a framework such as the ICUCARE instructional framework to examine evidence of student thinking and inform instructional decisions. By making this shift, teams can create a more equitable and effective approach to instruction, one that is focused on understanding and supporting student thinking.
Leave a Reply